The Sunset Crew Review: Is Black Indigo Terry Worth It?

When Taylor Stitch dropped the Sunset Crew in black indigo terry, it immediately caught our eye. The brand has built a reputation for rugged, well-made essentials, and this sweatshirt seemed poised to be another winner. But does it live up to the hype? We spent weeks wearing, washing, and scrutinizing every stitch to bring you this honest review.

The Sunset Crew is part of Taylor Stitch's core lineup, designed to bridge the gap between a casual hoodie and a more polished knit. With its clean lines and substantial fabric, it promises versatility. But with a price point that sits above your average sweatshirt, we wanted to know if the quality truly justifies the investment. Here's our deep dive.

First Impressions: Fabric and Feel

The first thing you notice about the Sunset Crew is the fabric. The black indigo terry is a heavyweight (around 12 oz) cotton that feels substantial without being stiff. It has a soft, brushed interior that makes it cozy against the skin, while the exterior has a smooth, clean look that can easily pass for a more tailored piece. The indigo dye gives it a rich, deep black that has a subtle sheen, and we appreciate that it doesn't feel like a typical black tee that fades quickly.

We also noticed the attention to detail in the construction. The stitching is tight and even, with reinforced seams at the shoulders and cuffs. The ribbing on the collar, cuffs, and hem is dense and holds its shape well. Taylor Stitch is known for its quality, and the Sunset Crew certainly feels like a premium product right out of the box.

• Heavyweight 12 oz cotton terry
• Brushed interior for softness
• Reinforced seams and durable ribbing

Fit and Sizing: How Does It Look?

The Sunset Crew has a classic, relaxed fit that is neither too baggy nor too slim. It drapes nicely over the shoulders and has a slightly tapered body that gives it a modern silhouette. The sleeves are cut to hit just at the wrist, and the body length is perfect for tucking or wearing untucked. We found that it runs true to size, but if you prefer a more oversized look, sizing up is a safe bet.

We tested the fit with a variety of outfits. It works well as a standalone piece with jeans or chinos, and it layers easily under a jacket like The Moto Jacket in Black Steerhide. The crew neck is not too tight, so it's comfortable, but it also provides enough structure to look sharp. Overall, the fit is one of the strongest aspects of this sweatshirt.

• True to size with a relaxed, modern fit
• Layers well under jackets
• Versatile for casual and semi-dressy looks

Durability and Care: Built to Last?

We put the Sunset Crew through the wringer: multiple wears, machine washes, and even a few outdoor adventures. The fabric held up remarkably well. There was minimal pilling, and the indigo color did not fade noticeably after several washes. We did notice a slight shrinkage in the length after the first wash, but it was minimal and didn't affect the overall fit.

The stitching remained intact, and the ribbing didn't stretch out or lose its shape. We also appreciated that the sweatshirt didn't pill under the arms or where it rubbed against backpack straps. This is a testament to the quality of the cotton and the construction. With proper care, this piece should last for years.

• Minimal pilling after multiple washes
• Color holds well with cold water washing
• Stitching and ribbing remain durable

Versatility: How to Style the Sunset Crew

One of the best things about the Sunset Crew is its versatility. The black indigo color makes it easy to pair with almost anything. We styled it with dark denim for a monochromatic look, and it also worked well with the earthy tones of The Yosemite Shirt in Delaware Plaid. For a more casual vibe, it pairs perfectly with The Apres Pant in Rinsed Indigo Sashiko, creating a coordinated yet relaxed outfit.

You can dress it up with a collared shirt underneath, letting the collar peek out, or keep it simple with a plain tee. It's also a great layering piece under a heavier coat like The Station Jacket in Petrol Blue Broken Twill. This sweatshirt is a true wardrobe workhorse.

• Pairs well with denim, chinos, and casual trousers
• Works as a layering piece under jackets
• Can be dressed up or down

Price and Value: Is It Worth It?

The Sunset Crew is priced higher than your typical sweatshirt, but you're paying for quality. The heavyweight fabric, meticulous construction, and timeless design justify the cost for those who value longevity. When you compare it to other premium brands, it's competitively priced, and Taylor Stitch's commitment to sustainability and ethical manufacturing adds to its appeal.

If you're looking for a sweatshirt that will last and can be worn in a variety of settings, the Sunset Crew is a solid investment. It's not the cheapest option, but it's one that will likely outlast cheaper alternatives, making it a better value in the long run.

• Premium pricing reflects high-quality materials and construction
• Long-term value due to durability
• Ethical manufacturing adds to the appeal

After weeks of testing, we can confidently say that the Sunset Crew in black indigo terry is worth every penny. Its combination of comfort, style, and durability makes it a standout piece in Taylor Stitch's lineup. Whether you're adding to your collection or looking for your first quality sweatshirt, this one is a winner. Check out the Sunset Crew and see for yourself why it's become a favorite.